0
items in Cart
Home
About
Menu
Catering
Specials
Contact
Order Online
0
items in Cart
Home
About
Menu
Catering
Specials
Contact
Order Online
Group Order
Sign Up For Deals
BENNY'S PIZZA
Online Ordering Menu
103 ROUTE 71
SPRING LAKE, NJ 07762
(732) 359-7611
10:30 AM - 8:00 PM
Start your carryout or delivery order.
Check Availability
Expand Menu
PIZZA SLICES
Grandma Slice
$3.00
Cheese Slice
$2.50
Sicilian
$3.00
Specialty Slice
$3.75
Slice 1 Topping
$3.00
Extra Topping
$0.50
White W/ Broccoli
$3.25
White Slice
$3.00
Two Toppings
$3.50
Panini
$8.50
Flat breadpizza
$6.00
Semitas
$8.50
Drinks
Small Drink
$1.25+
Large Drink
$2.25+
Snapple
$2.25
2 Liter
$3.50+
20oz
$2.25+
Bennys Soda
$2.25
Water Bottle
$1.50
Gatorade
$2.25
Snaple
$2.25
Lg.Pellegrino Drink
$4.00
S .Pellegrino Drink
$2.00
PERSONAL PIZZAS
Personal Plain
$10.00+
Personal WHITE SPINACH
$12.00+
Personal-WHITE PIZZA
$11.00+
Personal-WHITE BROCCOLI
$12.00+
Personal-VEGGIE DELIGHT
$12.00+
Personal-PENNE VODKA
$12.00+
Personal-MIXED GREENS SALAD PIZZA
$11.00+
Personal-MEAT LOVERS
$12.00+
Personal-MARGARITA
$12.00+
Personal-HAWAIIAN
$11.00+
Personal-EGGPLANT ROLLATINI
$12.00+
Personal-CHICKEN PARMESAN
$12.00+
Personal-CAESAR SALAD PIZZA
$11.00+
Personal-BUFFALO CHICKEN
$12.00+
Personal-BAKED ZITI
$12.00+
Personal-B.B.Q. CHICKEN
$12.00+
PERSONAL BENNYS SPECIAL PIZZA
$12.00+
Personal Italian
$11.00+
Personal Chicken Bacon Ranch
$14.00+
MEDIUM PIZZAS
Medium Plain
$13.50+
Medium Italian
$16.00
Medium Benny's Special
$20.00
Medium WHITE SPINACH
$16.00
Medium-WHITE PIZZA
$15.00+
Medium-WHITE BROCCOLI
$16.00
Medium-VEGGIE DELIGHT
$20.00
Medium-PENNE VODKA
$19.50
Medium-MIXED GREENS SALAD PIZZA
$18.00
Medium-MEAT LOVERS
$18.25
Medium-MARGARITA
$15.50+
Medium-HAWAIIAN
$18.00
Medium-EGGPLANT ROLLATINI
$18.00
Medium-CHICKEN PARMESAN
$16.95
Medium-CAESAR SALAD PIZZA
$18.00
Medium-BUFFALO CHICKEN
$16.95
Medium-BAKED ZITI
$19.25
Medium-B.B.Q. CHICKEN
$16.95
LARGE PIZZAS
Nona Pizza
$17.50+
L-WHITE PIZZA
$16.00+
L-HAWAIIAN
$20.25
L-B.B.Q. CHICKEN
$20.00
L-BUFFALO CHICKEN
$20.00
L-EGGPLANT ROLLATINI
$19.00
L-CHICKEN PARMESAN
$20.25
L-BAKED ZITI
$20.25
L-PHILLY CHEESESTEAK
$23.00
L-MARGARITA
$17.50+
L-MEAT LOVERS
$20.25
L-PENNE VODKA
$21.50
L-VEGGIE DELIGHT
$21.50+
L-WHITE BROCCOLI
$18.00+
L-WHITE SPINACH
$18.00+
L-MIXED GREENS SALAD Pizza
$17.00
L- CAESER SALAD PIZZA
$17.00
Gluten Free Pizza
$15.00+
Large Italian
$17.95+
Large Benny's Special
$21.50+
Large Plain
$15.00+
Large Sicilian Pizza
$17.50+
Large Chicken Bacon And Ranch Pizza
$23.00
Benny Mac Pizza (Large Only)
$24.00
Chicken, Red Roasted Peppers And Balsamic Glace Pizza ( Large Only)
$24.00
Bruschectta Pizza
$23.00
Wednesday LG 1 Special
$9.99+
Wednesday LG 2 Special
$10.00+
JUMBO PIZZAS
Jumbo Plain
$18.95+
Jumbo Italian
$21.95
Jumbo chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
$25.00
Jumbo Benny's Special
$27.00
Jumbo- WHITE SPINACH
$22.00
Jumbo -WHITE PIZZA
$20.00
J-WHITE BROCCOLI
$22.00
Jumbo -VEGGIE DELIGHT
$23.00
Jumbo-PENNE VODKA
$23.00
Jumbo-MEAT LOVERS
$23.00
Jumbo-MARGARITA
$20.50+
Jumbo-HAWAIIAN
$22.25
Jumbo-EGGPLANT ROLLATINI
$22.00
Jumbo-CHICKEN PARMESAN
$23.95
Jumbo-BUFFALO CHICKEN
$23.95
Jumbo BAKED ZITI
$23.00
Jumbo-B.B.Q. CHICKEN
$23.95
SALADS
APPLE SALAD
$9.50+
BUFFALO SALAD
$13.50+
CAESAR SALAD
$9.50+
ANITPASTA SALAD (FOR 1)
$10.00+
ANITPASTA SALAD (FOR 2)
$12.00+
CHOPPED SALAD
$9.50+
AVOCADO SALAD
$9.50+
AVOCADO SALAD W/CHICKEN
$13.50+
BENNY'S SPECIAL SALAD
$9.50+
TUNA TOSSED SALAD
$13.00+
GREEK SALAD
$9.50+
Caprese Salad
$12.00+
Goat Cheese Salad
$13.50+
Arugala Salad
$11.00+
Side Salad
$5.50+
Strawberry Salad
$9.50+
Watermelon Salad
$9.50+
APPETIZERS
Garlic Bread
$4.50
Garlic Bread with Cheese
$5.50
Muscles Marinara App
$10.00
Jalapeño Poppers
$6.25
Fried Calamari
$12.00
Buffalo Fried Calamari
$13.00
1/2 Dozen Garlic Knots
$3.50
1 Dozen Garlic Knots
$6.00
5 Buffalo Wings
$5.25+
10 Buffalo Wings
$9.25+
20 Buffalo Wings
$16.99+
50 Buffalo Wings
$37.75+
3 Pc. Chicken Tenders
$5.25+
6 Pc. Chicken Tenders
$7.99+
12 Pc. Chicken Tenders
$14.50+
24 Pc. Chicken Tenders
$33.45+
36 Pc. Chicken Tenders
$43.99+
Benny's Cold Antipasto
$16.00
Spicy Garlic Shrimp (For One) App
$17.00
Scarole, Sautee App
$10.00
Broccoli Rave And Sausage App
$12.00
Bakes Clams Oreganata (One Dozen) App
$16.00
Eggplant Rollatini App
$10.00
Muscles Canellini App
$15.50
French Fries
$4.00
Broccoli Garlic And Oil App
$7.00
Broccoli Rabe No Sausage App
$7.00
Cheese Fries
$5.00
XTRA DRESSING.
$0.65
SPICY SHRIMP APP 1
$15.00
Spicy Garlic Shrimp (For 2)
$28.00
5 Spicy Garlic Wings
$7.50+
10 Spicy Garlic Wings
$13.50+
CAPE COD CHIPS
$3.79
BIG BAG OF CHIPS
$2.99
Small Bag Of Chips
$1.25
Cookies
$1.00
CHICKEN PARM SLIDER
$4.75
5 BBQ WINGS
$5.25+
10 BBQ WINGS
$9.25+
20 BBQ WINGS
$16.99+
50 BBQ WINGS
$37.75+
French Fries
$4.00
Ch FF
$5.50
Side breaded Chix
$7.50
Side Grilled Chix
$5.00
Spinach Garlic And Oil
$7.00+
Blackened Salmon
$10.00
Grilled Salmon
$11.00
Side Mushed Potstoes
$0.00
Eggplant Parm Appetizers
$9.00
Garden Fresh Bruschetta For 1
$10.00
Kids Menu
Spaghetti With Butter Kids
$7.00+
Spaghetti With Meatball Kids
$8.00+
Spaghetti With Sausage Kids
$8.00+
Penne Marinara Kids
$8.00
Kids Ravioli
$8.00
Mozzarella Sticks
$7.00
Chicken Fingers & Fries
$7.50
Side Of Fries With Mozzarella Or Cheddar Cheese
$5.00
Kids Mozzarella Sticks, Chicken Fingers/fries
$9.00
Kids Chicken Parm
$9.00+
Kids Bolognese
$8.00+
Kids Penne Vodka
$9.00+
Side Of Meatballs
$6.00
Side Of Sausage
$6.00
Cavetelli And Broccoli Kids
$8.50
Cheese fries
$5.00
French fries
$4.00
Spaghetti W Tomato Sauce Kids
$6.00+
3 Chicken Fingers
$5.25+
6 Chicken Fingers
$7.99+
12 Chicken Fingers
$14.50+
Waiting
$0.00
PHILLY CHEESE STEAKS (1\2)
1/2-CHEESE STEAK
$8.00+
1/2-CHICKEN CHEESESTEAK
$8.00+
1/2-CHICKEN PIZZA STEAK
$8.00+
1/2-MEXICAN CHEESE STEAK
$8.00+
1/2-PLAIN STEAK W/ONIONS
$7.00+
1/2 PIZZA STEAK
$9.00+
1/2-CALIFORNIA CHEESESTEAK
$9.00+
1/2-BUFFALO CHK CHEESESTEAK
$8.00+
1/2-BENNYS SPECIAL CHEESESTEAK
$8.50+
1/2-BENNYS SPEC. CHK CHEESESTEAK
$9.00+
1/2-CALI CHK CHEESESTEAK
$8.00+
1/2-CST BACON & BBQ
$9.75+
PHILLY CHEESTEAKS (WHOLE)
WH-BACON & BBQ CST
$14.00+
WH-SPEC CHK CHEESESTEAK
$14.00+
WH-PLAIN STEAK W/ONIONS
$11.00+
WH-MEXICAN CHEESESTEAK
$13.00+
WH-CHICKEN PIZZA STEAK
$13.00+
WH-CHICKEN CHEESESTEAK
$14.00+
WH-CHEESE STEAK
$13.00+
WH-CALIFORNIA CHEESESTEAK
$14.00+
WH-CALI CHK CHEESESTEAK
$13.00+
WH-BUFFALO CHK CHEESESTEAK
$13.00+
WH-BENNYS SPECIAL CHEESESTEAK
$14.00+
WH PIZZA STEAK
$14.00+
Cold Subs(1/2)
1/2-#2
$7.50+
1/2-#1
$7.50+
1/2-TURKEY CLUB
$8.50+
1/2-#3
$7.50+
1/2-TUNA
$7.50+
1/2-TURKEY
$7.50+
1/2-ITALIAN
$7.50+
1/2-ROAST BEEF
$7.50+
1/2-PEPPERONI/CHEESE
$7.00+
TURKEY CLUB WRAP
$15.00+
1/2 Cheese Sub
$7.00+
COLD SUBS(Whole)
WH-#1 (HAM AND CHEESE)
$13.00+
WH-ROAST BEEF
$14.00+
WH-TURKEY
$14.00+
WH-TURKEY CLUB
$15.00+
WH-TUNA
$14.00+
WH-ITALIAN (HAM,CHEESE, SALAMI AND CAPICOLA)
$14.00+
WH-#2 (HAM,CHEESE, SALAMI)
$13.00+
WH-#3 (HAM,CHEESE AND CAPICOLA)
$13.00+
1/2 Cheese Sub
$7.25+
WH Italian Classic
$16.00+
W- Cheese Sub
$10.75+
TURKEY CLUB WRAP
$15.00+
HOT SUBS (1/2)
1/2-MEATBALL SUB
$6.50+
1/2-MEATBALL PARMIGIANA
$7.50+
1/2-SAUSAGE PARMIGIANA
$7.50+
1/2-SAUS/PEPP/ONIONS
$7.50+
1/2-EGGPLANT PARMIGIANA
$7.50+
1/2-CHICKEN PARMIGIANA
$8.50+
1/2-VEAL PARMIGIANA
$11.25+
1/2-CALIFORNIA CHICKEN
$8.50+
1/2-PIZZA SUB
$5.75+
1/2 Sausage Sub
$6.50+
1/2 Grilled Ck California
$8.50+
1/2 Veal California
$10.00+
HOT SUBS (WHOLE)
WH-CALIFORNIA CHICKEN
$13.00+
WH-CHICKEN PARMIGIANA
$14.00+
WH-EGGPLANT PARMIGIANA
$13.00+
WH-MEATBALL PARMIGIANA
$13.00+
WH-MEATBALL SUB
$11.00+
WH-SAUS/PEPP/ONIONS
$13.00+
WH-SAUSAGE PARMIGIANA
$13.00+
WH-SAUSAGE SUB
$11.00+
WH-VEAL PARMIGIANA
$17.00+
WHOLE BROCCOLI RABE AND SAUSAGE SUB
$15.00
Pepper egg potato
$10.00
WH -Grilled Ck California
$13.00+
WHOLE VEAL CALIFORNIA
$17.00+
PASTAS
HOMEMADE TOMATO SAUCE
$11.00+
W/MEATBALLS
$13.00+
W/SAUSAGE
$13.00+
W/GARLIC & OIL
$10.75+
W/ RED CLAM SAUCE
$15.00+
W/ WHITE CLAM SAUCE
$13.95+
ALFREDO SAUCE
$13.00+
RIGATONI BOLOGNESE
$14.00+
Gnocchi Pesto
$21.00
Gnocchi Margarita
$16.00
Penne Arrabiatta
$19.00+
Penne vodka
$14.50+
Cavateli And Brocoli
$13.50
W/ Marinara
$12.00+
PASTA WITH PESTO SAUCE ONLY
$12.00+
Pasta W/ Butter
$11.00+
PENNE VODKA
$14.50+
Linguini With Spicy Garlic Sauce
$15.00+
Desserts
CANNOLI
$4.50
LAVA CAKE
$6.00
TIRAMISU
$6.50
SPECIALTY WRAPS
BRD. Ck CAESAR WRAP
$10.50+
GRD Ck CAESAR WRAP
$10.50+
BUFFALO CHICKEN WRAP
$10.50+
BRD CHK-CHICKEN WRAP
$10.50+
GRD CHK-CHICKEN WRAP
$10.50+
GRILLED SALMON
$15.00+
Benny's Special Wrap
$11.75+
WRAP - CHEESE STEAK
$13.00+
TURKEY CLUB WRAP
$15.00+
Chicken Parm Wrap
$13.00+
BACON LETTUCE TOMATO
$11.00
Tuna Wrap
$14.00
SEAFOOD
SHRIMP PARMIGIANA
$20.00+
SHRIMP MARINARA
$17.00+
SHRIMP SCAMPI
$19.00+
SHRIMP FRANCESE
$20.00+
MUSSELS MARINARA Dinner
$16.50+
CALAMARI MARINARA
$18.00+
SEAFOOD FRADIAVOLO
$21.00+
Shrimp Scampi With Risotto
$21.00+
Salmon Canellini
$21.00+
Spicy Garlic Salmon
$21.00+
Salmon Picata
$21.00+
Linguini Spicy Garlic Shrimp
$19.00
Fettucini Sammer
$21.00
Clams With White
$15.00+
SCALLOPS AND SHRIMP MALOSSA.
$20.95+
Pescatore
$21.00+
Red Clam Sauce
$15.00+
Shrimp Gnocci
$21.00+
Grilled Salmon
$11.00
Shrimp Aurora
$21.00
Pescatore Over Broccoli Rabe
$21.00
Scallops And Shrimp Malossa
$22.00+
STROMBOLIS
Stromboli Chicken parm
$9.50+
Stromboli saus/peppers/onions
$9.00+
Stromboli Chicken & Brocoli
$10.00+
Strom. pepperoni & Cheese
$9.00+
Stromboli Ham& Cheese
$9.00+
Strom. Sausage & Cheese
$9.00
Strom. Meatballs & Cheese
$10.50
20" Pork Roll Egg And Cheese
$23.00
HOMEMADE SOUPS
BOWL-PASTA FAGIOLI
$5.50
BOWL-CHICKEN NOODLE SOUP
$5.50
BOWL-SOUP OF THE DAY
$5.00
Escarole And Beans Bowl
$5.50
Italian Wedding Soup
$5.50
Stratachiella Soup
$5.50
Ck Rice Soup
$5.50
CALZONES
SMALL Calzone
$8.00+
MEDIUM Calzone
$10.50+
LARGE Calzone
$17.00+
OVEN BAKED DISHES
STUFFED SHELLS.
$13.00+
MANICOTTI
$13.00
MEATY LASAGNA
$15.00+
RAVIOLI.
$13.00+
BAKED ZITI
$13.00+
Stuffed Rigattoni
$15.00+
Pasta Della Casa Benny's
Linguini With Escarole And Beans
$16.00
Chicken Broccoli Cavatelli
$16.00+
Ravioli Trattoria
$18.00
Fettucini Prince
$20.00
Rigattoni Alla Vodka
$13.95
Rigattoni Sorrento
$15.00+
Parpardella Spring
$19.00
Rigattoni Alla Carbonera
$19.00+
Garden Fresh Farfalle
$18.00
Rigatoni Hot sausage, Broccoli Rabe
$17.00+
Black Fettucini Visuvio
$23.00
Mezzi Zuchinni
$18.00
CHICKEN
Chicken Cranberries
$17.00+
Chicken Murphy
$18.00
Chicken Scarpariello
$18.00
Chicken Savoy
$19.00
Chicken Tuscan
$18.00+
Chicken Francaise
$16.50+
Chicken Astorino
$18.00+
Chicken Marsala
$16.50+
CK MILANESSE
$19.00
Chicken Parmigiana
$15.00+
Chicken Saltimbocca
$18.50+
Chicken Parm No Cheese
$16.00+
Chicken Picatta
$19.00
Chicken Margarita
$17.00+
VEAL
Veal Saltimboca
$20.00+
Veal Coast
$20.00+
Veal Gorgonzola
$21.00+
Veal Sorrento
$21.00+
Veal Goat
$21.00+
VEAL PARMIGIANA
$19.00+
Veal Milanese
$21.00+
Veal Picatta
$21.00
Veal Francaise
$22.00+
Veal Pizzaiola
$23.00+
Burgers
Cali Burger
$9.00+
Western Burger
$9.00+
Buffalo Burger
$9.00+
Jersey Burger
$10.00+
Plain Cheese Burger
$9.00+
Plain Hamburger
$8.00+
EGGPLANT
Eggplant Rollatini
$16.00+
Eggplant Parmigiana
$15.00+
Panini's
Panini
$8.50
Family Meals
Family Meals Chicken parm
$40.00+
Family meals Spaghetti And Meat Balls
$40.00+
Family meals Ravioli
$40.00+
Family Meals Stuffed Shells
$40.00+
Family Meal Manicotti
$40.00+
Special Pizza And sub
Plain Pizza W Cold Sub #1
$19.99+
Plain Pizza W Cold Sub #2
$19.99+
Plain Pizza W Cols Sub #3
$19.99+
1/2 Tray
1/2 Tray Chicken Parm
$40.00
1/2 Tray Mussels Marinara
$40.00+
1/2 Tray Spici Garlic Shrimp Platter
$60.00
1\2 Tray Escarole Saute
$40.00
1/2 Tray Fried Buffalo Calamari
$40.00
1/2 Tray Fried Calamari
$40.00
1/2 Tray Apple Salad
$35.00+
1/2 Tray Caprese Salad
$30.00
1/2 Tray Benny's Special Salad
$35.00+
1/2 Tray Benny's Cold Antipasto
$50.00
1/2 Tray Manicotti
$35.00
1/2 Tray Baked Ziti
$35.00
1/2 Tray Stuffed Shells
$35.00
1/2 Tray Lasagna
$40.00
1/2 Tray Penne Vodka
$35.00
1/2 Tray Cavatelli & Broccoli
$30.00
1/2 Tray Eggplant Parm
$40.00
1/2 Tray Eggplant Rollatini
$50.00
1/2 Tray Rigatoni W/ Broccoli Rabe
$40.00+
1/2 Tray SPO
$40.00
1/2 Tray MEAT BALLS
$40.00
full tray chicken par
$70.00
1/2 Tray Chicken Fingers
$40.00
1/2 Tray Chicken Savoy
$50.00
1/2 Tray Fries Buffalo & Regular Calamari
$40.00
1/2 Tray Veal Francese
$60.00
1/2 Tray Veal Marsala
$60.00
1/2 Tray Chicken Marsala
$40.00
1/2 Tray Chicken Francese
$45.00
1/2 Tray Chicken Murphy
$50.00
1/2 Tray Chicken Cranberry
$45.00
1/2 Tray Avocado Salad
$35.00
1/2 Tray Chopped Salad
$35.00
1/2 Tray Caesar Salad
$35.00
1/2 Tray Shrimp Francese
$60.00
1\2 Tray Mix Vegetables
$30.00
1/2 Tray FRENCH FRIES
$20.00
1/2 Tray Lasagna
$40.00
Full Tray
Full Tray Chicken Francese
$80.00
Full Tray Penne Vodka
$60.00
Full Tray Benny's Special Salad
$50.00
Full Tray Cavatalli And Broccoli
$50.00
Full Tray Mussels Marinara
$70.00
Full Tray Spicy Garlic Shrimp Platter
$120.00
Full Tray Escarole Saute
$70.00
Full Tray Fried Buffalo & Regular Calamari
$70.00
Full Tray Apple Salad
$50.00
Full Tray Caprese Salad
$60.00
Full Tray Avocado Salad
$60.00
Full Tray Benny's Cold Antipasto
$65.00
Full Tray Manicotti
$60.00
Full Tray Baked Ziti
$50.00
Full Tray Stuffed Shells
$50.00
Full TrayMeat Lasagna
$70.00
Full Tray Eggplant Parmesan
$70.00
Full Tray Eggplant Rollatini
$80.00
Full Tray Rigatoni With Broccoli & Sausage
$70.00
Full Tray Veal Francese
$100.00
Full Tray Veal Marsala
$100.00
Full Tray Chicken Marsala
$70.00
Full Tray Chicken Parm
$70.00
Full Tray Chicken Cranberry
$70.00
Full Tray Chicken Savoy
$90.00
Full Tray Chicken Murphy
$90.00
Full Tray Sausage, Peppers & Onions
$70.00
Full Tray Caesar Salad
$50.00
Full Tray Meat Balls
$70.00
Full Tray Shrimp Francese
$100.00
FULL TRAY Ck Fingers
$80.00
1/2 Tray Seafood Fradiablo
$120.00
Full Tray Of mashed Potatoes
$45.00
FULL TRAY Mixed Veggies
$60.00
Full Tray French Fries
$40.00
Full Tray Veal Parm
$120.00
Platters And Subs
Small Bruscheeta Platter
$25.00
Small Fresh Mozz And Tomato Platter
$30.00
Izzy's Handmade Pigs In A Blanket (100)
$50.00
Small Benny's Cold Antipasto Platter
$50.00
Medium Fresh Bruschetta Platter
$40.00
Medium Fresh Mozzarella And Tomato Platter
$40.00
Large Bruscheeta Platter
$60.00
Large Fresh Mozz And Tomatoe Platter
$60.00
Large Benny's Cold Antipasto Platter
$65.00
3ft Subs
$65.00+
4 Ft Subs
$90.00+
5 Ft Subs
$90.00+
6 Ft Sub
$160.00+
Sandwich Platter
$6.95
Wrap Platter
$6.95
Weekly Specials
Artichoke Franchise
$10.95
Fresh Pappardelle Sinatra
$18.00
Penne Shrimp Aurora
$19.99
Spicy Garlic Chicken Over Broccoli Rabe
$17.99
Mussels Napoli for 1
$11.00
Cherry Pepper Chicken
$18.99
Cajun Salmon with Brocoli Rabe
$23.00
Mussels Napoli for 2_
$19.00
Your cart is empty.
Close Cart
Checkout
$0.00
Loading, please wait.
View Cart
0
$0.00